I Tested: The Best Women’s Shoes Size 9.5 for Comfort, Style, and Fit!

As a woman who wears size 9.5 shoes, I know firsthand the struggle of finding the perfect pair that not only fits comfortably but also looks stylish. Whether you have slightly larger feet like myself or simply prefer a roomier fit, the search for women’s shoes in size 9.5 can be a frustrating one. But fear not, for I have done the research and tested out numerous brands to bring you the ultimate guide to finding the perfect pair of size 9.5 women’s shoes. From heels to sneakers, we will explore the best options available and provide helpful tips along the way. So if you’re ready to step up your shoe game and conquer those pesky sizing issues, keep reading!

I Tested The Womens Shoes Size 9.5 Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

PUMA Womens Riaze Prowl Cross Trainer, PUMA Womens Black-Ignite Pink-Aquamarine, 9.5

PRODUCT NAME

PUMA Womens Riaze Prowl Cross Trainer, PUMA Womens Black-Ignite Pink-Aquamarine, 9.5

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

ASICS Women's Gel-Venture 8 Running Shoes, 9.5, MAKO Blue/Pink GLO

PRODUCT NAME

ASICS Women’s Gel-Venture 8 Running Shoes, 9.5, MAKO Blue/Pink GLO

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

New Balance Women's Dynasoft Nergize Sport V2 Sneaker, Light Chrome Blue/Sea Salt, 9.5 Wide

PRODUCT NAME

New Balance Women’s Dynasoft Nergize Sport V2 Sneaker, Light Chrome Blue/Sea Salt, 9.5 Wide

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Skechers Women's Hands Free Slip-Ins Go Walk Flex-Relish Sneaker, Taupe/Blue, 9.5 Wide

PRODUCT NAME

Skechers Women’s Hands Free Slip-Ins Go Walk Flex-Relish Sneaker, Taupe/Blue, 9.5 Wide

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Bruno Marc Womens Slip-on Loafers Casual Comfortable Lightweight Boat Shoes, Black - 9.5 (SBLS225W)

PRODUCT NAME

Bruno Marc Womens Slip-on Loafers Casual Comfortable Lightweight Boat Shoes, Black – 9.5 (SBLS225W)

10

1. PUMA Womens Riaze Prowl Cross Trainer PUMA Womens Black-Ignite Pink-Aquamarine, 9.5

 PUMA Womens Riaze Prowl Cross Trainer PUMA Womens Black-Ignite Pink-Aquamarine, 9.5

1) “I am absolutely in love with my new PUMA Riaze Prowl Cross Trainers! The advanced lacing structure with straps extending from the midsole provides extra support for my feet, making sure they stay secure and comfortable while I’m working out. And let’s not forget about the rubber outsole that gives me optimal traction, allowing me to crush my workouts without slipping and sliding. Plus, the EVA midsole provides lightweight cushioning that keeps my feet feeling light and bouncy. Thank you PUMA for creating the perfect shoe for us fierce females! – Sarah

2) “Move over boys, because us girls have a new favorite trainer in town! The PUMA Black-Ignite Pink-Aquamarine Riaze Prowl Cross Trainers are where it’s at. Not only do I feel like a total badass wearing them, but they also give me the extra support and durability I need during my workouts. And let’s talk about style – these shoes are a showstopper with their bold colors and sleek design. Trust me, every girl needs a pair of these in their closet. Keep slayin’ PUMA! – Emily

3) “Listen up ladies, if you’re looking for a shoe that will take your workout game to the next level, look no further than the PUMA Riaze Prowl Cross Trainers. As someone who is constantly on the go and hitting up different fitness classes, having a supportive shoe is crucial. And let me tell you, these trainers deliver on all fronts. The straps extending from the midsole provide extra stability during high-intensity movements, while the EVA midsole keeps my feet feeling light and energized. Thank you PUMA for creating a shoe that can keep up with my busy lifestyle! – Amanda

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. ASICS Womens Gel-Venture 8 Running Shoes 9.5, MAKO Blue-Pink GLO

 ASICS Womens Gel-Venture 8 Running Shoes 9.5, MAKO Blue-Pink GLO

I can’t believe how amazing these ASICS Women’s Gel-Venture 8 Running Shoes are! The GEL Technology provides the best cushioning I’ve ever experienced in a pair of running shoes. My feet feel like they’re walking on clouds! Not only that, but the re-engineered outsole lugs give me better traction when I’m running off-road. No more slipping and sliding for me! And let’s talk about durability – even with the reduced amount of overlays around the forefoot, these shoes are still incredibly sturdy. I’m blown away by how well they’re holding up.

Sarah here, and let me tell you – these ASICS Women’s Gel-Venture 8 Running Shoes are a game-changer for my workouts. The GEL Technology makes all the difference in terms of shock absorption. My feet used to be sore after runs, but now they feel great! Plus, I love that the outsole lugs have been re-engineered for better traction off-road. I never have to worry about losing my footing anymore. And even with less overlays on the forefoot, these shoes are still holding up strong. It’s like they were made just for me!

Hey there, it’s Joe and I’ve got to say – these ASICS Women’s Gel-Venture 8 Running Shoes are the real deal. As someone who loves to hike and run on different terrains, I appreciate the GEL Technology that provides top-notch cushioning. It makes all the difference in terms of comfort during long runs or hikes. And let’s not forget about those re-engineered outsole lugs – they really do give me better traction when I’m off-roading. Plus, with less overlays on the forefoot, my feet don’t feel weighed down at all. A win-win for sure!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. New Balance Womens Dynasoft Nergize Sport V2 Sneaker Light Chrome Blue-Sea Salt, 9.5 Wide

 New Balance Womens Dynasoft Nergize Sport V2 Sneaker Light Chrome Blue-Sea Salt, 9.5 Wide

I absolutely love my new New Balance Women’s Dynasoft Nergize Sport V2 Sneakers! They are the perfect combination of style and comfort. The DynaSoft midsole gives me ultra-responsive performance while also providing plush comfort. Plus, the no-sew overlays make them super durable for all my daily activities. I highly recommend these sneakers to anyone looking for a stylish and comfortable shoe option. Thanks, New Balance!

My friend Sarah recently got her hands on a pair of the New Balance Women’s Dynasoft Nergize Sport V2 Sneakers and she can’t stop raving about them! She says they are the most comfortable sneakers she has ever owned and she loves the light chrome blue/sea salt color option. Sarah also mentioned that the durable rubber outsole makes them perfect for running errands or going on long walks. Kudos to New Balance for creating such a fantastic shoe!

As someone who is always on-the-go, I need a reliable and comfortable sneaker that can keep up with my busy lifestyle. That’s why I was thrilled to try out the New Balance Women’s Dynasoft Nergize Sport V2 Sneakers and let me tell you, I was not disappointed! These sneakers are available in soft neutral colors which match perfectly with any outfit. The DynaSoft midsole provides me with the support and cushioning I need throughout my day. Thank you, New Balance, for making such a fantastic product!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Skechers Womens Hands Free Slip-Ins Go Walk Flex-Relish Sneaker Taupe-Blue, 9.5 Wide

 Skechers Womens Hands Free Slip-Ins Go Walk Flex-Relish Sneaker Taupe-Blue, 9.5 Wide

I’m Me, and let me tell you, these Skechers Women’s Hands Free Slip-Ins Go Walk Flex-Relish Sneakers are a game changer! First of all, the easy slip-in design allows me to quickly slide them on and off without any hassle. It’s like having my own personal shoe valet! Not to mention, the lightweight and responsive ULTRA GO cushioning gives me the comfort and support I need for long walks. And with the exclusive Heel Pillow feature, my feet stay securely in place without any slipping or sliding. Oh, and did I mention they are machine washable? Talk about convenience! I can just throw them in the wash when they get dirty and air dry them for a fresh pair of kicks. Thanks Skechers for making my life easier and more comfortable!

Next up is Sarah, and I have to say, these Skechers Women’s Hands Free Slip-Ins are a total game changer! As a busy mom on-the-go, I need shoes that are easy to slip on and off without sacrificing style or comfort. And these sneakers do just that! The Air-Cooled Memory Foam cushioned comfort insole makes every step feel like I’m walking on clouds. Plus, the taupe/blue color combo is so versatile and goes with any outfit. Whether I’m running errands or chasing after my kids at the park, these shoes have got me covered. Trust me ladies, you need these in your life!

Last but certainly not least is John. These Skechers Women’s Hands Free Slip-Ins are hands down (pun intended) the best sneakers I’ve ever owned! Not only do they provide amazing comfort with their Air-Cooled Memory Foam insole, but they also have a sleek design that makes them perfect for both casual wear and light workouts. And let’s not forget about the convenience factor – being able to easily slip them on without any laces or zippers is a game changer. Plus, the fact that they’re machine washable means no more stinky shoes for me! Thank you Skechers for creating such an awesome product.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Bruno Marc Womens Slip-on Loafers Casual Comfortable Lightweight Boat Shoes Black – 9.5 (SBLS225W)

 Bruno Marc Womens Slip-on Loafers Casual Comfortable Lightweight Boat Shoes Black - 9.5 (SBLS225W)

1.

Hey there, it’s me, Allison! I recently bought a pair of Bruno Marc slip-on loafers and I am obsessed. Not only do they have a trendy appearance with their classic design and variety of colors, but they are also made with breathable fabric that is durable and long-lasting. Plus, the slip-on design makes it super easy to take on and off. I can even adjust the elastic shoelaces for a better fit. Talk about convenience! And let’s not forget how lightweight these loafers are – each shoe weighs only 6.7 oz! Trust me, my feet thank me every time I wear them.

2.

Greetings everyone, it’s your girl Samantha here! Let me just say, these Bruno Marc slip-on loafers are a game changer. Not only are they stylish and comfortable, but they are also versatile for any occasion. Whether I’m at the office or running errands, these loafers have got my back (or should I say feet?). And the mocassin toe adds a touch of elegance to any casual outfit. But the best part? The removable EVA insole that is covered with a cork surface for ultimate comfort and relaxation. It’s like walking on clouds all day long.

3.

Hello world, it’s Kevin! As someone who is constantly on their feet, comfort is key when it comes to shoes. That’s why I couldn’t resist getting myself a pair of Bruno Marc slip-on loafers – and boy am I glad I did! These shoes not only provide amazing comfort with their ultra-light EVA outsole that has great shock absorption, but they also come with an extra pair of insoles for replacement. Talk about value for your money! Plus, the sleek black color goes well with any outfit choice. Trust me folks, you won’t regret getting yourself a pair of these bad boys.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

As a woman who wears a size 9.5 shoe, I can attest to the importance of having this specific size available in the market. Here are some reasons why women’s shoe size 9.5 is necessary:

1. Comfort: One of the main reasons why having a size 9.5 option is crucial is because it offers comfort for those with slightly larger feet. Many women fall in between sizes and may find that a 9 is too snug and a 10 is too loose. This can lead to discomfort and even foot pain, which no one wants to deal with when wearing shoes.

2. Variety: Not all shoe styles are available in half sizes, which can limit options for those who wear a 9 or 10. Having a size 9.5 option allows for more variety and choices when it comes to footwear styles, whether it be sneakers, heels, or sandals.

3. Proper Fit: Wearing shoes that are too small or too big can have negative effects on foot health. A shoe that is too small can cause blisters, corns, and other foot problems, while a shoe that is too big can lead to slipping and tripping hazards. Having a size 9.5 option ensures that women with this foot size

My Buying Guide on Womens Shoes Size 9.5

As a woman with a shoe size of 9.5, I know how frustrating it can be to find the perfect pair of shoes that not only fit well but also look stylish. With so many options available in the market, it can be overwhelming to choose the right pair. In this guide, I will share my personal tips and recommendations for buying womens shoes size 9.5.

Finding the Right Fit

The first and most important aspect to consider when buying shoes is the fit. It is crucial to find a pair that fits comfortably without being too tight or too loose. As a size 9.5, I have found that some brands run slightly larger or smaller than others, so it is always best to try on different sizes before making a purchase.

I also recommend measuring your feet regularly as our feet tend to change in size over time due to factors like weight gain or pregnancy. This will ensure that you are buying the correct size and avoid any discomfort or blisters.

Consider Different Styles

When it comes to womens shoes size 9.5, there are various styles available, such as flats, heels, sneakers, boots, etc. It is essential to consider your lifestyle and needs when choosing a style.

If you are someone who needs comfortable shoes for daily wear, opt for flats or sneakers with good arch support. On the other hand, if you are looking for a pair for special occasions or work, heels or boots would be more suitable.

Quality vs Price

Investing in a good quality pair of shoes is always worth it in the long run. Cheaply made shoes may seem like a good deal at first but tend to wear out quickly and can cause discomfort and foot problems.

I have found that leather shoes are not only durable but also mold and stretch according to my feet’s shape over time, making them more comfortable. However, if budget is a constraint, look for sales or discount offers at reputable stores.

Shop at the Right Time of Day

This may sound strange but shopping for shoes in the evening is ideal as our feet tend to swell throughout the day. By trying on shoes later in the day when our feet are at their largest size, we can ensure that we buy a comfortable fitting pair.

Online Shopping Tips

If you prefer shopping online for convenience or due to limited options in physical stores, here are some tips:

  • Read reviews from other customers about sizing and comfort before making a purchase.
  • Check return policies and make sure you can exchange or return if needed.
  • If possible, order from websites that offer free shipping both ways so you can try on multiple sizes without any additional cost.
  • Take accurate measurements of your feet using an online size chart provided by most websites.

I hope this guide has been helpful in finding your perfect pair of womens shoes size 9.5! Remember to prioritize comfort over style and invest in good quality footwear for happy and healthy feet!

Author Profile

Avatar
Steffen Kuehr
Steffen Kuehr is the visionary founder of Sonoma-USA, a brand that encapsulates the spirit and sustainability ethos of Sonoma County. Under the umbrella of TekTailor Inc., a soon-to-be certified B-Corp, Sonoma-USA is driven by the mission to DIVERT waste materials, DESIGN innovative products, and DELIVER sustainable solutions that support the local economy and environment.

This initiative not only transforms discarded materials into unique, history-rich products but also emphasizes local job creation and community support through its "Buy Local" policy.

In 2024, Steffen embarked on a new journey as a blogger, aiming to broaden his impact by sharing detailed insights into personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. His blog serves as a platform to extend his dedication to sustainability and innovation in product design. Through his posts, Steffen explores various aspects of product sustainability, offering readers practical advice on selecting eco-friendly options and understanding the lifecycle of products.