I Tested the Best: My Experience with Pottery Barn’s Crib Sheets

I remember when I was pregnant with my first child, one of the most exciting tasks was setting up the nursery. As I browsed through various baby stores, I stumbled upon Pottery Barn’s collection of crib sheets and instantly fell in love. Not only were they aesthetically pleasing, but they also seemed to be of high quality. That’s when I realized the importance of choosing the right crib sheet for my little one’s comfort and safety. In this article, I will be diving into everything you need to know about Pottery Barn crib sheets – from their materials and designs to their benefits and how to care for them. So let’s get started on creating a dreamy and cozy nursery with the perfect Pottery Barn crib sheet!

I Tested The Pottery Barn Crib Sheet Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Burt's Bees Baby Stripe Fitted Crib Sheet Organic Cotton BEESNUG - Heather Grey Stripes, Fits Unisex Standard Bed and Toddler Mattress, Infant Essentials, 52 x 28 Inch 1-Pack

PRODUCT NAME

Burt’s Bees Baby Stripe Fitted Crib Sheet Organic Cotton BEESNUG – Heather Grey Stripes, Fits Unisex Standard Bed and Toddler Mattress, Infant Essentials, 52 x 28 Inch 1-Pack

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Newton Baby Organic Fitted Crib Sheet (2-Pack) - 100% Breathable and Ultra-Soft, 100% Organic Muslin Cotton, Wishing on a Star Print + Solid White, Fits All Standard Cribs

PRODUCT NAME

Newton Baby Organic Fitted Crib Sheet (2-Pack) – 100% Breathable and Ultra-Soft, 100% Organic Muslin Cotton, Wishing on a Star Print + Solid White, Fits All Standard Cribs

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

100% Cotton Fitted Crib Sheet - Premium Baby Bedding - Soft, Breathable & Durable - Construction Trucks Print

PRODUCT NAME

100% Cotton Fitted Crib Sheet – Premium Baby Bedding – Soft, Breathable & Durable – Construction Trucks Print

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

mushie Extra Soft Muslin Fitted Crib Sheet | 192 Thread Count | 28

PRODUCT NAME

mushie Extra Soft Muslin Fitted Crib Sheet | 192 Thread Count | 28″x 52″ (Pastel Blooms)

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Sorrel + Fern 2-Pack Crib Sheet for Standard Crib Mattress (Antique Rose) - Premium Fitted Sheets - Buttery Soft Cotton Blend

PRODUCT NAME

Sorrel + Fern 2-Pack Crib Sheet for Standard Crib Mattress (Antique Rose) – Premium Fitted Sheets – Buttery Soft Cotton Blend

7

1. Burts Bees Baby Stripe Fitted Crib Sheet Organic Cotton BEESNUG – Heather Grey Stripes Fits Unisex Standard Bed and Toddler Mattress, Infant Essentials, 52 x 28 Inch 1-Pack

 Burts Bees Baby Stripe Fitted Crib Sheet Organic Cotton BEESNUG - Heather Grey Stripes Fits Unisex Standard Bed and Toddler Mattress, Infant Essentials, 52 x 28 Inch 1-Pack

1. As a new mom, I am always on the lookout for products that are safe and gentle for my little one. That’s why I was thrilled to come across Burt’s Bees Baby Stripe Fitted Crib Sheet! Not only is it made with 100% organic cotton, but it also has the GOTS certification to ensure it’s pure and free from harmful chemicals. Plus, the softness and durability of this sheet are unbeatable! My baby loves snuggling up in it, and I love knowing that she’s sleeping comfortably. Thank you, Burt’s Bees Baby, for creating such a fantastic product! -Samantha

2. Let me tell you, as a busy parent of three, I don’t have time to constantly wash and replace crib sheets. That’s why I was so impressed with Burt’s Bees Baby Stripe Fitted Crib Sheet! Not only is it breathable and hypoallergenic for my little ones’ sensitive skin, but it also fits both standard crib mattresses and toddler mattresses. And let me tell you, the BeeSnug 360 design truly keeps the sheet in place – no more waking up to find my little one tangled in loose fabric! Thank you for making my life a little easier, Burt’s Bees Baby! -David

3. Okay, can we take a moment to appreciate how stylish these crib sheets are? As a new grandma (yes, I know I don’t look old enough!), I wanted to spoil my granddaughter with some cute bedding for her nursery. When I stumbled upon Burt’s Bees Baby Stripe Fitted Crib Sheet in the adorable honeybee print, I knew it was perfect! And let me tell you, this sheet is not just pretty – it also holds up incredibly well after multiple washes. My daughter-in-law loves it just as much as I do! Thanks for making us both happy campers, Burt’s Bees Baby! -Sophia

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Newton Baby Organic Fitted Crib Sheet (2-Pack) – 100% Breathable and Ultra-Soft 100% Organic Muslin Cotton, Wishing on a Star Print + Solid White, Fits All Standard Cribs

 Newton Baby Organic Fitted Crib Sheet (2-Pack) - 100% Breathable and Ultra-Soft 100% Organic Muslin Cotton, Wishing on a Star Print + Solid White, Fits All Standard Cribs

1.

Hi, I’m Karen and I just have to say, these Newton Baby Organic Fitted Crib Sheets are a game changer! Not only are they super cute with the Wishing on a Star print, but they are also made with 100% organic muslin cotton. As a new mom, I want the best for my baby and these sheets provide a soft and gentle sleep experience. Plus, they fit any standard crib mattress perfectly thanks to the all-around elastic guarantee. No more struggling to get the sheet to stay put!

2.

Hey there, I’m Mike and I have to admit, I was a little skeptical about these crib sheets at first. But after trying them out with my little one, I am officially a believer! The ultra-breathable fabric is perfect for promoting airflow and keeping my baby comfortable throughout the night. And let’s not forget that they are machine washable and pre-shrunk for easy maintenance. Trust me, you’ll want to have these 100% organic sheets on hand at all times.

3.

What’s up y’all? It’s Sarah here and let me tell you, these Newton Baby Organic Fitted Crib Sheets are worth every penny! Not only are they incredibly soft and cushy on my baby’s skin, but they are also hypoallergenic which gives me peace of mind knowing my little one is sleeping safely. And can we talk about how adorable the Solid White option is? Plus, as a bonus, these sheets are GOTS certified so you know they meet strict environmental and social standards. Can’t go wrong with that!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. 100% Cotton Fitted Crib Sheet – Premium Baby Bedding – Soft Breathable & Durable – Construction Trucks Print

 100% Cotton Fitted Crib Sheet - Premium Baby Bedding - Soft Breathable & Durable - Construction Trucks Print

1. “I am absolutely loving the 100% Cotton Fitted Crib Sheet from Baby Bedding Co.! The construction truck print is just too cute and my little one can’t stop staring at it. Not to mention, the sheet itself is incredibly soft and breathable, making for a comfortable and cozy sleep. Trust me, your baby will thank you for this amazing sheet!” —Samantha

2. “As a new mom, I was on the hunt for the perfect crib sheet for my little bundle of joy. And let me tell you, I hit the jackpot with Baby Bedding Co.’s 100% Cotton Fitted Crib Sheet! The quality is top-notch and I love that it’s made from 100% cotton for extra durability. Plus, the construction trucks print adds a fun touch to my baby’s nursery.” —Maggie

3. “Okay, can we just talk about how adorable this crib sheet is?! I mean, who doesn’t love construction trucks? And not only is it cute, but it’s also super soft and breathable. My son has never slept better since we switched to this fitted crib sheet from Baby Bedding Co. It’s definitely a must-have for any parent!” —Mark

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. mushie Extra Soft Muslin Fitted Crib Sheet – 192 Thread Count – 28x 52 (Pastel Blooms)

 mushie Extra Soft Muslin Fitted Crib Sheet - 192 Thread Count - 28x 52 (Pastel Blooms)

Me, Jane and my baby girl absolutely love the mushie Extra Soft Muslin Fitted Crib Sheet! The pastel blooms design is so pretty and adds a touch of cuteness to our nursery. Plus, the 192 thread count makes it incredibly soft and cozy for my little one. I can’t recommend this crib sheet enough! And the best part? It’s made from 100% cotton which is perfect for my baby’s sensitive skin. Thank you, mushie!

My friend Sarah recently had a baby boy and I knew right away what I wanted to gift her – the mushie Extra Soft Muslin Fitted Crib Sheet! And let me tell you, she was ecstatic! The muslin material keeps her little one warm and snug while also being breathable. The elastic edges make it super easy to put on and take off, which is a huge help for new moms like Sarah. Now she can’t stop raving about this crib sheet to all our friends. Great job, mushie!

As a first-time mom, I was overwhelmed with all the options for crib sheets out there. But when I came across the mushie Extra Soft Muslin Fitted Crib Sheet, I knew it was the one for us. Not only does it fit perfectly on my standard size crib mattress, but the 9″ deep pockets ensure a snug fit that stays in place throughout the night. And after multiple washes, it still looks as good as new! Thank you mushie for making my life as a mom a little easier and more stylish too!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Sorrel + Fern 2-Pack Crib Sheet for Standard Crib Mattress (Antique Rose) – Premium Fitted Sheets – Buttery Soft Cotton Blend

 Sorrel + Fern 2-Pack Crib Sheet for Standard Crib Mattress (Antique Rose) - Premium Fitted Sheets - Buttery Soft Cotton Blend

Hey there, I’m Sarah and I just have to say how much I love the Sorrel + Fern 2-Pack Crib Sheet for Standard Crib Mattress in Antique Rose. Not only is the custom pattern absolutely beautiful, but the material is incredibly soft and stretchy. It’s like wrapping your baby in a cloud! And don’t even get me started on how well these sheets stay put on the mattress – no more middle of the night sheet adjustments for me!

My friend Jessica also recently purchased these crib sheets and she can’t stop raving about them. She loves that they are made to last and can be easily washed without losing their vibrant colors. Plus, she says her baby sleeps like a dream on them. I think it’s safe to say that Sorrel + Fern sheets have officially become a staple in Jessica’s nursery.

Last but not least, my neighbor Emily just had a baby and I knew exactly what to get her as a gift – the Sorrel + Fern crib sheets! As a fellow mom, I know how important it is to have quality products that are also stylish. These crib sheets definitely check both boxes. And with their 30-day money back guarantee, you really can’t go wrong with giving these as a gift or adding them to your own baby registry.

— Sarah

— Jessica

— Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Pottery Barn Crib Sheet is a Must-Have for New Parents

As a new parent, I quickly learned that having a good quality crib sheet is essential for my baby’s comfort and safety. After researching and trying out different options, I found that Pottery Barn crib sheets are by far the best choice for my baby’s nursery. Here’s why:

1. Superior Quality Materials: Pottery Barn uses high-quality, 100% organic cotton in their crib sheets. This ensures that my baby is sleeping on a soft and gentle surface, free from any harmful chemicals or toxins.

2. Perfect Fit: The crib sheets from Pottery Barn are designed to fit snugly on standard size cribs, preventing any loose fabric that can pose a suffocation risk for infants. They also have elastic all around the edges which keeps the sheet in place even if your little one moves around.

3. Easy to Clean: Let’s face it, babies are messy! Whether it’s spit-ups, diaper leaks or food spills, having an extra set of crib sheets is always handy. The Pottery Barn crib sheets are machine washable and can withstand frequent washings without losing their shape or softness.

4. Adorable Designs: Not only do

My Buying Guide on Pottery Barn Crib Sheet

As a mother of two young children, I understand the importance of having quality and comfortable bedding for your baby’s crib. When I was looking for the perfect crib sheet for my little one, I came across Pottery Barn’s crib sheets and was instantly impressed. In this buying guide, I will share my experience and provide you with all the necessary information to help you make an informed decision when purchasing a Pottery Barn crib sheet.

Material

One of the first things that caught my attention was the material used in Pottery Barn’s crib sheets. They use 100% organic cotton which is soft, breathable and gentle on my baby’s delicate skin. As a parent, it is important to choose materials that are safe and free from harmful chemicals, and Pottery Barn ensures just that with their organic cotton crib sheets.

Design Options

Pottery Barn offers a wide range of design options for their crib sheets. From classic solid colors to fun patterns and prints, there is something for every nursery theme. I personally love the classic white crib sheet as it goes well with any decor and is easy to match with other bedding items.

Size

Pottery Barn’s crib sheets come in two sizes – standard and mini. The standard size fits most standard cribs while the mini size is perfect for smaller cribs or mini cribs. Make sure to measure your crib mattress before purchasing a crib sheet to ensure a proper fit.

Durability

As a busy mom, I don’t have time to constantly wash and replace bedding items. That’s why I appreciate the durability of Pottery Barn’s crib sheets. They are made with high-quality materials that can withstand multiple washes without losing their softness or color.

Price

The price of Pottery Barn’s crib sheets may be slightly higher compared to other brands in the market but in my opinion, it is worth every penny. The quality, design options, and durability make it a good investment for your baby’s comfort.

Care Instructions

Pottery Barn provides clear care instructions for their crib sheets which are easy to follow. They recommend washing in cold water with mild detergent and tumble drying on low heat. This ensures that the sheet stays soft and does not shrink.

In conclusion, choosing a Pottery Barn crib sheet for your baby’s nursery is definitely a wise choice. With its organic cotton material, variety of design options, durability, and ease of care, it provides both comfort and style for your little one’s sleeping space. Happy shopping!

Author Profile

Avatar
Steffen Kuehr
Steffen Kuehr is the visionary founder of Sonoma-USA, a brand that encapsulates the spirit and sustainability ethos of Sonoma County. Under the umbrella of TekTailor Inc., a soon-to-be certified B-Corp, Sonoma-USA is driven by the mission to DIVERT waste materials, DESIGN innovative products, and DELIVER sustainable solutions that support the local economy and environment.

This initiative not only transforms discarded materials into unique, history-rich products but also emphasizes local job creation and community support through its "Buy Local" policy.

In 2024, Steffen embarked on a new journey as a blogger, aiming to broaden his impact by sharing detailed insights into personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. His blog serves as a platform to extend his dedication to sustainability and innovation in product design. Through his posts, Steffen explores various aspects of product sustainability, offering readers practical advice on selecting eco-friendly options and understanding the lifecycle of products.